SIOUX CITY -- The soft sobbing began as soon as the word "guilty" came from District Judge Tod Deck's mouth.
Two families hoping for opposite verdicts, experiencing the same reaction.
One family relieved at the thought of justice for a little girl whose life ended prematurely. The other family distraught, knowing a loved one had just been found guilty of a crime that will land him in prison for the rest of his life.
After roughly two hours of deliberations, a Woodbury County jury of six men and six women on Wednesday found Tayvon Davis guilty of first-degree murder, child endangerment resulting in the death of a child and multiple acts of child endangerment for the August 2018 death of 19-month-old Maelynn Myers, who never regained consciousness after Davis and Maelynn's grandmother rushed the unresponsive girl to a Sioux City emergency room. She died three days later at an Omaha hospital.
Davis showed no visible emotions after the verdicts were announced.
People are also reading…
Maelynn's family immediately left the courtroom after the verdict and went to the Woodbury County Attorney's Office to meet with prosecutors. A victims advocate said the family did not wish to make a statement.
Davis' family, as well as public defenders Jennifer Solberg and Laury Kleinschmidt, also declined to comment.
Davis, 26, of Sioux City, faces a mandatory sentence of life in prison for murder. The other two charges both carry 50-year prison sentences. Deck did not immediately set a sentencing date.
Prosecutors said the death was the result of weeks of abuse by Davis. He told investigators he had dropped the girl after giving her a bath, and she stopped breathing.
Throughout six days of trial, prosecutors used witness testimony and evidence to convince jurors that Davis injured the girl numerous times while watching the child in the Sioux City apartment he shared with the girl's mother, Shannon Myers. The girl's health had deteriorated since Aug. 1, the beginning of a period in which Davis spent more time watching the girl alone while Myers was at work. In Maelynn's final three weeks of life, Myers and her mother took the girl to the doctor repeatedly for illnesses and other physical ailments doctors struggled to diagnose. The night before she lost consciousness, Maelynn was a sluggish child who hardly touched her favorite meal of McDonald's chicken nuggets and french fries.
In closing arguments, Assistant Iowa Attorney General Nicole Leonard showed jurors a photo of Maelynn hooked up to a ventilator in the hospital. None of the defense's arguments that Maelynn was accidentally hurt when Davis dropped her or tried to revive her could explain the toddler's severe injuries.
"That little girl didn't end up this way because of CPR. That little girl ended up this way because the defendant repeatedly beat her until her body broke down and couldn't take it anymore," Leonard said.
A medical examiner ruled Maelynn's death a homicide caused by blunt-force injuries. The girl's long list of injuries included bruising on her forehead and back, bleeding throughout the brain, a torn blood vessel to her left kidney, hemorrhaging in both eyes, the abdomen and in the muscles at the back of her neck, bone fractures -- both new and healing -- in both legs, an arm, two vertebrae and several ribs.

Tayvon Davis, left, looks into the gallery while seated next to public defender Laury Kleinschmidt June 9 during the first day of his first-degree murder trial in Woodbury County District Court. Jurors on Wednesday found him guilty of the August 2018 death of 19-month-old Maelynn Myers.
Medical experts disagreed on the possible causes. The state's witnesses concluded the injuries were caused by trauma of a force similar to being in a car crash. A defense expert disagreed, offering alternative medical explanations that, he concluded, showed the injuries were accidental or occurred naturally because Maelynn had stopped breathing for several minutes before she was revived in the emergency room.
The fact doctors couldn't agree should raise enough reasonable doubt in jurors' minds to acquit Davis, Kleinschmidt said in the defense's closing arguments.
"This isn't an intentional murder," she said. "Tayvon Davis is not a monster. Tayvon Davis did not beat Maelynn to death."
The state's witnesses didn't even offer any ideas how Davis might have caused the injuries, Kleinschmidt said, and ignored Davis' explanation and the fact that the girl's mother and grandmother also spent long hours alone with Maelynn.
"It's a case about the search for a reason why and the search for someone to blame for the loss of a child," Kleinschmidt said.
But those injuries all had one thing in common, Assistant Woodbury County Attorney Kristine Timmins said. According to doctors' estimates on the age of the injuries, all fit into a time period when Davis spent several days watching Maelynn by himself.
"She wasn't in a car accident. She wasn't in a multi-story fall. She was with the defendant," Timmins said.
Lowest-earning counties in Iowa
Lowest-earning counties in Iowa

Americans on the whole were doing well financially heading into 2020, with major markers like unemployment reaching 50-year lows. The pandemic changed all that: During the second quarter of the 2020 fiscal year, our nation’s real GDP fell by a whopping 31.4%, a number that hasn’t been seen since the Great Depression. Since then the GDP has recovered, the first quarter of 2022 was 11% above the fourth quarter of 2019.
While GDP has recovered since the height of the pandemic, wage growth has not kept pace with inflation. In 2021 average hourly wages increased 4.7% while there was 7% inflation, meaning the worker’s purchasing power dropped by 2.4%.
Where you live can make a big impact on your financial situation. The highest earning county in the U.S. earns $147,111, while the lowest earns $22,292. Stacker compiled a list of the lowest-earning counties in Iowa using data from the U.S. Census Bureau. Counties are ranked by the Census’ 2020 5-year estimate median household income.
You may also like: Most popular girl names in the 80s in Iowa
#50. Howard County

- Median household income: $56,709
--- 8.3% below state average, 12.7% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.6%
--- #1,683 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 7.5%
--- #1,954 highest among all counties nationwide
#49. Emmet County

- Median household income: $56,708
--- 8.3% below state average, 12.7% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.2%
--- #1,756 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 7.7%
--- #1,953 highest among all counties nationwide
#48. Butler County

- Median household income: $56,473
--- 8.7% below state average, 13.1% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 20.3%
--- #1,558 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 9.8%
--- #1,935 highest among all counties nationwide
#47. Clayton County

- Median household income: $56,456
--- 8.7% below state average, 13.1% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.7%
--- #1,656 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 8.9%
--- #1,934 highest among all counties nationwide
#46. Palo Alto County

- Median household income: $56,437
--- 8.7% below state average, 13.2% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 21.6%
--- #1,333 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 8.5%
--- #1,932 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: Highest-rated Class of 2022 football recruits from Iowa
#45. Mahaska County

- Median household income: $56,417
--- 8.8% below state average, 13.2% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 20.4%
--- #1,536 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 12.7%
--- #1,929 highest among all counties nationwide
#44. Cherokee County

- Median household income: $56,302
--- 8.9% below state average, 13.4% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 23.6%
--- #1,039 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 10.0%
--- #1,921 highest among all counties nationwide
#43. Kossuth County

- Median household income: $56,156
--- 9.2% below state average, 13.6% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.9%
--- #1,626 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.1%
--- #1,910 highest among all counties nationwide
#42. Cerro Gordo County

- Median household income: $56,082
--- 9.3% below state average, 13.7% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 21.6%
--- #1,333 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 8.5%
--- #1,905 highest among all counties nationwide
#41. Ringgold County

- Median household income: $55,970
--- 9.5% below state average, 13.9% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 20.8%
--- #1,475 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 8.0%
--- #1,893 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: Best places to live in Iowa
#40. Montgomery County

- Median household income: $55,761
--- 9.8% below state average, 14.2% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 22.7%
--- #1,169 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 9.5%
--- #1,876 highest among all counties nationwide
#39. Humboldt County

- Median household income: $55,707
--- 9.9% below state average, 14.3% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 22.7%
--- #1,169 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.5%
--- #1,870 highest among all counties nationwide
#38. Adair County

- Median household income: $55,700
--- 9.9% below state average, 14.3% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.8%
--- #1,637 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 9.4%
--- #1,869 highest among all counties nationwide
#37. Franklin County

- Median household income: $55,630
--- 10.0% below state average, 14.4% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 17.8%
--- #1,986 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 14.7%
--- #1,865 highest among all counties nationwide
#36. Allamakee County

- Median household income: $55,523
--- 10.2% below state average, 14.6% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 20.7%
--- #1,492 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 9.2%
--- #1,855 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: Highest rated IPAs in Iowa
#35. Calhoun County

- Median household income: $55,285
--- 10.6% below state average, 14.9% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 20.7%
--- #1,492 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 10.9%
--- #1,827 highest among all counties nationwide
#34. Clarke County

- Median household income: $55,078
--- 10.9% below state average, 15.3% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.9%
--- #1,626 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 15.4%
--- #1,811 highest among all counties nationwide
#33. Hardin County

- Median household income: $54,930
--- 11.2% below state average, 15.5% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 18.5%
--- #1,874 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 10.8%
--- #1,793 highest among all counties nationwide
#32. Crawford County

- Median household income: $54,849
--- 11.3% below state average, 15.6% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 22.1%
--- #1,259 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.8%
--- #1,781 highest among all counties nationwide
#31. Black Hawk County

- Median household income: $54,774
--- 11.4% below state average, 15.7% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 23.0%
--- #1,126 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.0%
--- #1,777 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: Highest-rated football recruits from Iowa over the last 20 years
#30. Tama County

- Median household income: $54,749
--- 11.5% below state average, 15.8% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 20.1%
--- #1,587 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.2%
--- #1,775 highest among all counties nationwide
#29. Henry County

- Median household income: $54,490
--- 11.9% below state average, 16.2% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.9%
--- #1,626 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 8.7%
--- #1,749 highest among all counties nationwide
#28. Ida County

- Median household income: $54,219
--- 12.3% below state average, 16.6% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 20.3%
--- #1,570 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.5%
--- #1,718 highest among all counties nationwide
#27. Buena Vista County

- Median household income: $54,014
--- 12.6% below state average, 16.9% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 20.9%
--- #1,466 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 7.1%
--- #1,700 highest among all counties nationwide
#26. Lucas County

- Median household income: $53,967
--- 12.7% below state average, 17.0% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 18.9%
--- #1,804 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 13.8%
--- #1,697 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: Colleges with the best ROI in Iowa
#25. Poweshiek County

- Median household income: $53,925
--- 12.8% below state average, 17.0% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 24.6%
--- #921 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.4%
--- #1,690 highest among all counties nationwide
#24. Pocahontas County

- Median household income: $53,573
--- 13.4% below state average, 17.6% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 18.9%
--- #1,804 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 8.9%
--- #1,648 highest among all counties nationwide
#23. Adams County

- Median household income: $52,287
--- 15.4% below state average, 19.6% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 15.8%
--- #2,366 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 10.5%
--- #1,514 highest among all counties nationwide
#22. Clinton County

- Median household income: $52,221
--- 15.5% below state average, 19.7% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.7%
--- #1,656 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 10.9%
--- #1,504 highest among all counties nationwide
#21. Lee County

- Median household income: $52,072
--- 15.8% below state average, 19.9% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 17.5%
--- #2,042 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 9.8%
--- #1,480 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: What to know about workers' compensation in Iowa
#20. Keokuk County

- Median household income: $52,012
--- 15.9% below state average, 20.0% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 20.1%
--- #1,587 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 10.9%
--- #1,468 highest among all counties nationwide
#19. Cass County

- Median household income: $52,005
--- 15.9% below state average, 20.0% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 18.0%
--- #1,961 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.4%
--- #1,467 highest among all counties nationwide
#18. Webster County

- Median household income: $51,909
--- 16.1% below state average, 20.1% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 18.6%
--- #1,868 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 12.7%
--- #1,454 highest among all counties nationwide
#17. Monona County

- Median household income: $51,866
--- 16.1% below state average, 20.2% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.7%
--- #1,651 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 12.4%
--- #1,447 highest among all counties nationwide
#16. Des Moines County

- Median household income: $51,784
--- 16.3% below state average, 20.3% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 21.4%
--- #1,371 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 12.6%
--- #1,437 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: Highest-rated museums in Iowa
#15. Floyd County

- Median household income: $51,768
--- 16.3% below state average, 20.3% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.9%
--- #1,626 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 10.7%
--- #1,434 highest among all counties nationwide
#14. Winnebago County

- Median household income: $51,581
--- 16.6% below state average, 20.6% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 19.7%
--- #1,656 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 8.2%
--- #1,403 highest among all counties nationwide
#13. Clay County

- Median household income: $51,259
--- 17.1% below state average, 21.1% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 18.6%
--- #1,855 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.6%
--- #1,360 highest among all counties nationwide
#12. Wright County

- Median household income: $51,221
--- 17.2% below state average, 21.2% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 17.3%
--- #2,087 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 7.8%
--- #1,353 highest among all counties nationwide
#11. Page County

- Median household income: $51,196
--- 17.2% below state average, 21.2% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 17.2%
--- #2,106 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.5%
--- #1,348 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: Most popular girl names in the 60s in Iowa
#10. Greene County

- Median household income: $51,098
--- 17.4% below state average, 21.4% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 18.8%
--- #1,821 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 9.7%
--- #1,329 highest among all counties nationwide
#9. Union County

- Median household income: $50,375
--- 18.5% below state average, 22.5% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 18.9%
--- #1,804 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 10.6%
--- #1,257 highest among all counties nationwide
#8. Van Buren County

- Median household income: $49,898
--- 19.3% below state average, 23.2% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 15.4%
--- #2,445 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 11.7%
--- #1,196 highest among all counties nationwide
#7. Fayette County

- Median household income: $49,834
--- 19.4% below state average, 23.3% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 17.1%
--- #2,120 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 12.2%
--- #1,192 highest among all counties nationwide
#6. Audubon County

- Median household income: $49,245
--- 20.4% below state average, 24.2% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 14.4%
--- #2,589 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 9.4%
--- #1,125 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: Best counties to live in Iowa
#5. Decatur County

- Median household income: $48,154
--- 22.1% below state average, 25.9% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 14.9%
--- #2,521 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 14.4%
--- #1,015 highest among all counties nationwide
#4. Wayne County

- Median household income: $47,543
--- 23.1% below state average, 26.9% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 15.1%
--- #2,499 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 10.2%
--- #961 highest among all counties nationwide
#3. Jefferson County

- Median household income: $47,401
--- 23.3% below state average, 27.1% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 17.6%
--- #2,023 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 14.3%
--- #946 highest among all counties nationwide
#2. Wapello County

- Median household income: $46,433
--- 24.9% below state average, 28.6% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 17.3%
--- #2,087 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 13.0%
--- #858 highest among all counties nationwide
#1. Appanoose County

- Median household income: $39,693
--- 35.8% below state average, 38.9% below national average
- Households earning over $100k: 12.4%
--- #2,818 highest among all counties nationwide
- Households earning less than $15k: 16.1%
--- #336 highest among all counties nationwide
You may also like: Counties with the oldest homes in Iowa